The first time my four-year-old threw a wooden block at the wall, I said exactly what my own mother used to say: “Stop crying. You’re fine.” The words came out before I even thought about them. He wasn’t fine, obviously. A block doesn’t fly across the room because someone is fine. But “you’re fine” was the script I had, the one I grew up with, the one that felt like the right thing to say until I watched his tiny face crumple even harder and realized I had just taught him that his feelings were an inconvenience to me. Nobody warned me that talking to kids about emotions starts with examining your own relationship with feelings first.
I didn’t know how to talk to my kid about emotions. Talking to kids about emotions isn’t covered in prenatal classes or pediatrician checkups. Nobody teaches you this. The parenting books I skimmed at 2 AM while nursing talked about sleep schedules and feeding intervals and milestone charts. None of them had a chapter called “What to do when your child is so angry he forgets how to use words.” So I did what a lot of moms do: I winged it, and I got it wrong a lot.
The Day I Stopped Saying “Calm Down”: What Talking to Kids About Emotions Taught Me
There was a moment that changed things for me. My son was melting down because his banana broke in half, a tragedy of epic proportions if you are four, and I heard myself say “calm down” for the third time in two minutes. He looked at me with this mix of fury and confusion, like I had asked him to speak French. And it hit me: he doesn’t know what “calm down” means. He doesn’t know how. Nobody has ever shown him.
I started reading about emotional literacy, which is a fancy way of saying talking to kids about emotions in words they actually understand. The idea is simple enough: before a child can manage an emotion, they need to recognize it. But I was a 34-year-old woman who still sometimes couldn’t tell if I was angry or just hungry, so I wasn’t exactly an expert. I decided to learn alongside him.
What Color Are Your Feelings Today?
The question that seemed ridiculous at first became the one that worked. Instead of asking “are you sad?” or “why are you angry?”, questions that put him on the spot, I started asking, “what color are your feelings right now?”
Red, he said one afternoon after his best friend at preschool played with someone else at recess. Then he told me red was the color of the inside of his chest when he wanted to scream. He didn’t have the word “jealous.” He didn’t know “rejected.” But he knew red.
Some days his feelings are yellow, which means he has too much energy and his legs need to run. Some days they’re gray, which means he doesn’t want to talk and just wants to sit next to me on the couch. I don’t always get the color code right. Once he told me his feelings were “sparkly rainbow” and I thought that meant happy. Turns out it meant he had eaten half a bag of chocolate chips while I was in the bathroom. But the point is, the conversation started. There was a door I could knock on, and he began to open it.
The Mistake I Made Over and Over
Here is something I am embarrassed to admit: for the first year of trying to do better, I still messed up constantly. I would sit with him through a tantrum, validate his feelings with all the right words, and then ruin it five minutes later by snapping “why are you still crying about this?” The gap between knowing what to do and actually doing it, when you have not slept properly in four years and someone has just spilled yogurt on the one clean couch cushion, is a wide one.
I learned that the hard part is not the technique. The technique is easy to learn. The hard part is regulating my own emotions while I am trying to teach him to regulate his. I can’t tell him “it’s okay to be angry” through gritted teeth and expect the lesson to land. Kids read your body before they hear your words. My son knows when my “I’m listening” face is actually my “please stop talking so I can think” face.
Three Things That Finally Made Talking to Kids About Emotions Click (And One That Backfired)
I am not a child psychologist. I am a mom who tried a lot of things, failed at some, and kept the ones that worked in our particular household. Your kid might be different. Mine is a hurricane in Spider-Man pajamas.
1. We named feelings when nothing was wrong. Waiting until a tantrum to teach emotional vocabulary is like trying to teach someone to swim during a flood. We started naming feelings during calm moments: in books, in cartoons, in the grocery store. “That lady looks frustrated because the line is long.” “Bluey looks disappointed.” It felt unnatural at first, like I was narrating a nature documentary, but after a few weeks it became normal.
2. I apologized when I got it wrong. This one was humbling. I had to say things like, “I yelled because I was tired, not because you were bad. That was my fault, not yours.” The first time I did it, he looked at me like I had grown a second head. The fifth time, he said, “It’s okay, Mama. Your feelings were red too.” I cried. Not going to pretend I didn’t.
3. We made a calm-down corner, not a time-out corner. This was my husband’s idea. It’s just a beanbag chair with a few books and a little jar of glitter water. When things got loud, either of us, including me, could go sit there. No punishment attached. Sometimes I go there by myself, and my son brings me a stuffed animal and says, “You need a minute, Mama?” Which is both adorable and a little humiliating, but I’ll take it.
The thing that backfired: I bought a feelings chart, one of those posters with cartoon faces showing different emotions. I hung it on the fridge with magnetic stars. For two days my son used it earnestly. On day three he realized he could move the magnet to “angry” whenever I said no to cookies, and he weaponized it. I took the chart down. Some tools are best left to classrooms.
You Cannot Teach What You Have Not Learned
Something shifted when I stopped treating emotional conversations as a parenting technique and started treating them as a relationship. I wasn’t trying to manage him anymore. I was trying to know him.
Along the way I realized how much of my own emotional vocabulary was missing. I grew up in a house where we didn’t talk about feelings. Sad was weak. Anger was disrespectful. Fear was for babies. I spent most of my twenties not knowing I was anxious because I thought anxiety was just “being dramatic.” Teaching my son to name his feelings forced me to name my own. That was unexpected, and harder than I thought it would be.
I wrote about this tension before, the struggle between taking care of everyone else and remembering that I exist too, in my piece about feeling selfish for taking morning walks. The thread is the same: I cannot give my child emotional tools I don’t have myself. I need to build them first, or at least build them alongside him.
Last Night at Bedtime
Last night my son was upset about something that seemed small to me — a toy he couldn’t find, I think. Before I could speak, he said, “Mama, my feelings are purple. Purple means I’m sad and also a little bit mad at the same time.”
I didn’t fix it. I didn’t tell him the toy would turn up tomorrow. I just said, “Purple is a hard color. Do you want me to sit with you in the purple for a while?”
He nodded. We sat. After a minute he climbed onto my lap and whispered, “It’s turning blue now. Blue is a little sad but mostly okay.”
I don’t know if this is the right way to do it. There are probably child development experts who would say the color system lacks academic rigor or that I should have used a more structured emotional coaching model. I don’t care. My son has a way to tell me what is happening inside him, and he uses it. That feels like a win, in the same way figuring out the transition to two kids felt like a win — messy, imperfect, but ours.
Talking to kids about emotions is not about getting it right every time. It is about showing up and trying, even when your own emotional vocabulary is still under construction.
If you are at the beginning of this, still saying “you’re fine” because it’s the only script you know, you are not broken and neither is your kid. You just need a different script. Maybe it’s colors. Maybe it’s weather: cloudy, stormy, sunny. Maybe it’s animals — today I feel like a roaring lion, today I feel like a turtle that wants to hide. It doesn’t matter what system you invent. What matters is that the invitation is real: tell me how you feel, and I will listen without trying to fix it right away.
I am still learning to extend that same invitation to myself.
Leave a Reply